

William Butler Yeats
"A Dialogue of Self and Soul"
Show Notes
A re-presentation of my Poetry for Men episode from October 2022 featuring William Butler Yeats' "A Dialogue of Self and Soul." I return to new episodes, interviews, and guests next week, on January 10, 2025. Happy New Year, and see you then. -Will
Read โA Dialogue of Self and Soulโ https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poemโฆ
Transcript
0:00
[Music]
0:10
hello my name is Will Spencer and welcome to the will Spencer podcast this is a weekly Show featuring in-depth
0:16
conversations with authors leaders and influencers who help us understand our changing World new episodes release
0:23
every Friday this is just a quick reminder that I'm still on vacation this week returning after the holiday for all
0:30
new episodes beginning on Friday January 10th I'm very excited with the guests I have lined up and the new topics will be
0:37
exploring together it's been quite a year for me as you can imagine more than just the Rebrand went down there was my
0:44
brief involvement with the craziness in the reformed world as well and though I got right with God over all of it as
0:50
hard as it is to believe many people seem to think that I've chosen the wrong side perhaps the madness is far more
0:58
widespread than we know so it means a lot that you're still here listening and
1:03
I'm looking forward to continuing the adventure and to making new friends along the way this week I'll be
1:09
replaying one of my favorite episodes of all time my poetry for Men episode featuring William Butler Yates a
1:16
dialogue of self and soul can you believe that this episode was recorded more than 2 years ago I think it's one
1:23
of the finest examples of how my Christian faith has transformed me and how we're all a work in progress because
1:30
as you'll hear me say when I started working on this review of the poem I saw it one way but as I researched Yates and
1:37
his a cultic background that changed not only my perceptions of him but also of
1:43
the poem and the episode overall I had to go back to the drawing board at least
1:48
two or three times to create an episode that I felt represented my faith and
1:53
glorified the god I was coming to know so I share this with you again as a sort of mile marker to see how far we've
2:01
traveled together once again I'll see you all for all new episodes starting next week and please enjoy this
2:08
representation of my poetry for Men episode a dialogue of self and Soul by
2:13
William Butler Yates this episode I'm staying with
Yeats History & Background
2:20
contemporary poets and exploring the work of one of the most towering literary figures of the 20th century
2:26
William Butler Yates I put a lot of time into selecting the poem this week seeing as I originally chose it for my 2-year
2:32
anniversary I wanted to make it count I considered works by Robert Frost go and
2:38
roomie all of which were personally important to my life and story but ultimately I wanted to read something
2:43
with a more Universal appeal we get to those other works in time besides it's
2:48
hard to argue with a Nobel Prize William Butler Yates was born in 1865 in County
2:54
Dublin Ireland part of the so-called Protestant ascendancy the Protestant anglo-irish minority that was
3:00
influential in all aspects of Irish life since the 1700s the key part of that is
3:06
angirish the ascendancy considered themselves English people that happened to be born in Ireland but in the late
3:12
19th century the ascendancy began to decline haha as Irish nationalism took hold and the Irish Catholics became more
3:19
prominent in Irish culture in 1997 the biographer RF Foster quoted Napoleon's
3:26
dicum that to understand the man you have to know what was happening in the world when he was 20 and said that is
3:32
manifestly true of Yates and the more I think of it the more that seems true for me as well this nationalist shift in
3:39
Irish culture when Yates was in his 20s had a profound effect on his life and writing he was originally schooled at
3:46
home by his mother and father but then he transitioned to boarding school where his performance was described as quote
3:52
only fair perhaps better in Latin than in any other subject very poor in
3:57
spelling for all you underachieve There's Hope for a Nobel Prize yet Yates
4:03
began writing when he was 17 in 1882 and his first poems were published in 1885
4:09
in the Dublin University review then in 1888 he and his family moved to a new
4:14
home in London and Wikipedia notes that the rent for the house was 50 per year in addition to poetry Yates
4:22
also wrote plays novelas short stories and More in 1890 Yates joined the
4:27
Hermetic Order of the Golden Dawn which is a ritual magical order based on the teachings of the Hermetic cabala as well
4:34
as astrology tarot Alchemy and more these are subjects I happen to know a few things about as part of his
4:41
admission into the Golden Dawn he took the magical motto Damon Deus inversus
4:47
translated Devil Is God inverted shocking as that sounds that description is accurate but that discussion is
4:54
outside the bounds of this podcast in 1892 Yates wrote quote the mystical life
5:00
is the center of all that I do and all that I think and all that I write hold on to that statement and I know that
5:06
Yates was far from alone in his Endeavors because there was a massive surge of interest in the occult driven
5:12
by a movement which at the time was called vitalism theosophy and Rosicrucianism were also part of this
5:19
larger movement which helped give birth to Alistair Crowley who called himself the wickedest man alive in his own words
5:26
Crowley desired to be Satan's Chief of Staff he also went on to influence generations of rock stars artists
5:33
scientists and more when I discovered yates's interest in the occult and 32
5:38
years long membership in the Golden Dawn I strongly considered canceling this poem and studying something else but I
5:45
stuck with it and went on an Epic Journey that I hope will have relevance to my listeners and to this important
5:51
historical moment we find ourselves in because this information is deeply relevant to the poem itself and speaks
5:57
into aspects of the poem's core message message that I was trying to figure out how to address in the proper way also as
6:04
we'll see Yates gets a bunch of other things right so this will be an important lesson about attribution of
6:10
ultimate Authority and that's all I'll say for now so thanks history and thanks
6:16
to cie Robertson from caffeine and philosophy for alerting me that this information was out there because now I
6:22
get to tackle it head on moving on around the same time as Yates developed
6:28
his interest in occultism he also met John oi a former Irish nationalist who
6:33
had returned from Exile following the shifting cultural winds in Ireland like many from the British Isles during the
6:39
height of Empire Yates had fostered a romantic interest in foreign countries like India but as a 25-year-old man
6:45
under O's influence he took to heart O's advice that Irish writers should write about Irish subjects Yates would later
6:52
write quote when I first wrote I went here and there for my subjects as my reading led me and preferred to all
6:59
other Arcadia and the India of romance but presently I convinced myself that I
7:04
should never go for the scenery of a poem to any country but my own and I think that I shall hold to that
7:10
conviction to the end in 1886 Yates also met a tall beautiful socially prominent
7:16
woman named ma gone g n NE who sought Yates out following the publication of
7:22
one of his poems now brace yourself because things are about to get wild and you're going to get a taste of what I
7:29
discovered when I went digging Yates grew obsessed with gone considering her his Muse but he never actually became
7:36
involved with her in those early days due in part to her activism on behalf of the Irish nationalist cause which had
7:42
her living in Ireland whereas Yates preferred the contemplative artist life in London however he traveled to Ireland
7:49
to propose to her in 1891 and she declined later he said from that point
7:55
quote the troubling of my life began he proposed three more times in 1899 1900
8:02
and 1901 and was rejected each time then ma married in 1903 choosing the famous
8:10
Irish nationalist Major John McBride for her husband who fought in the South African boow war and for the men
8:17
listening it shouldn't come as a surprise that the beautiful young woman chose The Dashing former military
8:23
officer over the gifted but contemplative artist perhaps it should also not come as a surprise that the
8:29
marriage of of the Beauty and the soldier was a disaster during their marriage ma frequently traveled to
8:34
Ireland to continue her activism work leaving McBride In Paris she would later
8:39
write that despite her warnings to her husband he became friends with the journalist Victor Collings Who quote
8:45
introduced him to a rather undesirable drinking set who usually foregathered in the American Bar he had an unhappy life
8:52
in Paris he did not know a word of French and must often have been very lonely as my work kept me much in IR
8:59
Maryland what Ma didn't mention was that she was also visiting Yates in London during her trips as well presumably to
9:06
unload her troubles on him so for those keeping score at home we've got hypergamy feminism and orbiters but it
9:13
continues after the birth of their son Ma and McBride decided to split and a divorce proceeding ensued in 1905 less
9:21
than 2 years after their marriage they were not granted a divorce by the French courts however in part because none of
9:28
Ma's accusations towards her husband held up in court except for one night of drunkenness but the court did Grant a
9:34
separation to the couple with custody to the mother and visitation rights to the father remember we're talking about 1905
9:42
almost 120 years ago some things never change but it continues in 1908 Yates
9:49
and mgon finally consummated their long relationship almost 20 years after his first proposal apparently another one of
9:56
his lovers described it as quote the long years of Fidel rewarded at last
10:01
while Yates himself remarked about it saying quote the tragedy of sexual intercourse is the Perpetual virginity
10:07
of the soul to me this suggest Yates was dissatisfied with the experience which
10:13
is perhaps understandable for they met in their early 20s and did not consummate things until their 40s this
10:19
can't possibly live up to the potential of youthful passions in full bloom but I'm
10:25
speculating either way their night together did not lead to a relationship ma would later write to Yates quote I
10:32
have prayed so hard to have all Earthly desire taken from my love for you and dearest loving you as I do I have prayed
10:39
and am praying still that the bodily desire for me will be taken from you too
10:44
and in January 1909 she was writing to him about the advantage given to artists who abstain from sex ouch for his part
10:53
Yates would later recall the night in his poem a man young and old he wrote my arms are like the Twisted Thorn and yet
11:00
there Beauty lay the first of all the tribe lay there and did such pleasure take she who had brought great Hector
11:07
down and put all Troy to wreck what's most tragic about this is the
11:13
unavoidable note of bitterness and what of Major John McBride in 1905 he
11:18
returned to Dublin and joined other Irish nationalists in planning an Insurrection but as a former Soldier
11:25
well known to the British McBride was left out of the important meetings as a result he found himself in the middle of
11:31
the famed Irish 1916 Easter Rising by accident as history goes he was on his
11:38
way to meet his brother Dr Anthony McBride who had arrived in Dublin to be married that week on the way to meet his
11:44
brother at the train station on that very day Easter Sunday Major John McBride turned up Grafton Street and
11:51
happened to bump into Thomas McDon another poet playwright and activist and one of the seven leaders of the Easter
11:56
rising and signatory of the proclamation of the Irish Republic McDon was leading his uniformed troops marching towards
12:04
the start of the Easter Rising conflict Major John McBride offered his services to the cause and was accepted as a
12:10
participant under McDon who was commandant of the second Battalion Dublin Brigade of the Irish volunteers
12:17
McBride MCD and the soldiers fought in Jacob's biscuit Factory one of the major
12:22
battles of the Rising for military Scholars I found a link where you can read witness statements about the Battle
12:28
and more that's in the show notes the rising was put down by the British after 7 days and Major John McBride was tried
12:36
convicted and executed by firing squad less than a month later on May 5th
12:41
facing the British firing squad McBride declined to be blindfolded he saide I
12:47
have looked down the muzzles of too many guns in the South African War to fear death and now please carry out your
12:54
sentence respect Yates who believed Major John M bride stole his Muse mod
13:00
gone wrote an ambivalent eulogy in his poem Easter 1916 about the uprising he
13:06
wrote this other man I had Dreamed a drunken vain glorious lout he had done
13:11
most bitter wrong to some who are near my heart yet I number him in the song he
13:17
too has resigned his part in the Casual comedy he too has been changed in his
13:22
turn transformed utterly a terrible beauty is born to which mgon replied in
13:29
letter quote no I don't like your poem it isn't worthy of you and above all it isn't worthy of its subject as from my
13:36
husband he has entered eternity by the great door of sacrifice so that praying for him I can also ask for his prayers a
13:44
bust of Major John McBride stands in his native Westport County Mayo in Ireland a
13:49
photo of that is linked in the show notes as well there's a lot I can say about all this but first one of my
13:55
favorite things about doing these episodes is how my research into the history of these poets takes me further
14:01
a field than I can ever imagine it also colors the interpretation of the poem
14:06
which you'll see second Wikipedia is often full of misinformation distortions
14:12
and misunderstandings but there are moments where it's hard not to appreciate the Glorious gift of a wealth of information
14:18
like this maybe I should start a History Podcast third for those working their
14:23
red pill scorecard we've racked up hypergamy feminism beta orbiters Sigma
14:28
check ads no fault divorce sing white nighting single motherhood pity sex and
14:35
more if someone would be kind enough to send this to rot tomasi I think he'd enjoy it fourth and finally if you think
14:42
your life is full of drama just be thankful you're not an artist just as I was about to close out
14:48
this segment I found more information that concludes the story between Yates and mod gon Yates proposed to her again
14:55
in 1916 after McBride's death a Proposal with yates's biographer notes was
15:01
motivated more by a sense of Duty than any genuine desire to marry Christopher
15:06
kill in the Atlantic wrote that mgon may have had a chloroform addiction at the time as well one way or another yates's
15:13
indifferent proposal was declined so according to yates's biographer he turned his attention to isil mod gon's
15:20
21-year-old daughter from a previous marriage if you're wondering where Isel came from ma had previously been in a
15:26
relationship with the French journalist and WR Wing politician Lucien miloy through the 1880s and90s the
15:34
relationship produced two children first a son who died of menitis at around a
15:39
year old and a daughter isil who was conceived and this is a direct quote as
15:45
an attempt to reincarnate her deceased brother isil was conceived in
15:50
1894 ma married Major John McBride in 1903 for the intervening years ma
15:57
presented Isel as her adopted niece Isel never liked McBride and the French
16:03
Divorce Court heard allegations that he had sexually assaulted her allegations which as stated earlier didn't hold up
16:10
at age 15 in 1909 isil proposed to Yates he was 44 at the time so he declined but
16:17
8 years later in 1917 he proposed when Israel was 21 and he was rejected Yates
16:24
got shot down by a mother and her daughter I told you things would get wild but we're not even even done yet
16:30
then September that same year 1917 as Yates was approaching age 52 he proposed
16:36
to a woman named Georgie Hyde Le aged 25 despite her friends warnings they
16:41
married and apparently their marriage was a great success the couple had two children but in later years Yates proved
16:49
Unfaithful Georgie wrote to Hime when you were dead people will talk about your love affairs but I shall say
16:56
nothing for I will remember how proud you were ouch but at least they shared some
17:02
things in common are you ready Georgie had also been part of Golden Dawn so
17:07
together they enjoyed a love for seances spiritism and the Occult beginning 4
17:13
days after their wedding Georgie held a series of 400 sessions of automatic writing where you allegedly let Spirits
17:20
guide your hand as you write to communicate their information this produced more than 4,000 pages that
17:26
Yates obsessed over so at least there's that I promise you this will all be
17:32
relevant to the poem You may be wondering by this point if Yates had any time to write indeed for many years he
17:39
was part of the Abbey theater company whose Manifesto read quote we hope to find in Ireland an uncorrupted and
17:45
imaginative audience trained to Listen by its passion for oratory and that freedom to experiment which is not found
17:52
in the theaters of England and without which no new movement in art or literature can succeed he wrote 10 plays
17:59
with his company he also collaborated with the famous American poet Ezra pound
18:04
who served as a secretary and inspired yates's fascination with the Japanese no style of theater into these forms Yates
18:11
wo his interest in Irish culture folklore and mythology in his poetry he used symbolism in both structure and
18:18
imagery and as he matured into a middle-aged poet he left behind the Lush and dramatic style of his youth for a
18:24
style that critics have described as quote Supple and muscular the famous Irish poet Sheamus Haney said of him
18:31
regarding this transition quote he is indeed the ideal example for a poet approaching middle age he reminds you
18:38
that revision and slog work are what you may have to undergo if you seek the satisfaction of finish he bothers you
18:45
with the suggestion that if you have managed to do one kind of poem in your own way you should cast off that way and
18:51
face into another area of your experience until you have learned a new voice to say that area
18:57
properly later in life Yates began to come into his own as an Irish Statesman
19:03
Ireland began its war for independence in 1919 and finally achieved it in
19:08
1921 Yates won the Nobel Prize for literature in 1923 which the Nobel committee said was
19:14
for quote his always inspired poetry which in a highly artistic form gives
19:20
expression to the spirit of a whole nation Yates used this opportunity to become a prominent Irish Senator and
19:26
advocate for his Nation as part of Europe's free states but the split between Protestant and Catholic Irish
19:32
began to express itself in those early days of the nation a divide which he warned about while in office his book
19:39
sales following his Nobel Prize also made him very wealthy and he used the money to pay both his debts and those of
19:45
his father and as much as I like to tell you that the weirdness ended in his old age that's not true in 1934 at age 68 he
19:55
had what was called a Steck operation which is a half fac toy Stein's theory
20:00
was that the sperm and vital essence of two testicles would be concentrated in one with resulting benefit to potency
20:07
and vigor Steiner later became famous for helping to discover the role between testosterone and estrogen and human
20:14
physical identifiers and he also helped develop the original transgender
20:19
surgery it should not be a surprise then that transgenderism is connected to the
20:25
occult though steex vasectomy operation was eventually discredited and yates's
20:30
case it seems to have worked Yates wrote in a letter quote I find my present weakness made worse by the strange
20:36
second puberty the operation has given me the ferment that has come upon my imagination if I write poetry it will be
20:44
unlike anything I have done this also explains his late life infidelity to his
20:49
wife Georgie in 1935 and 1936 Yates traveled to mayorca to study with an
20:55
indian-born Swami to translate the Hindu the pon aads an effort inspired by
21:00
yates's mystical leanings Yates died in France in 1939 at age 73 and is
21:07
currently buried in a humble grave near his boyhood home in County silgo he wrote of his old Agee now that my lad's
21:15
gone I must lie down where all the ladders start in the foul Rag and Bone shop of the heart if you recognize that
21:22
last phrase it's the title of the compilation by Robert blly James Hilman and Michael me that helped Inspire The
21:29
Poetry for men's series and from which I took this poem while all this information challenged my commitment to
21:35
journalistic Integrity for it would not otherwise be my intention to document a man who lived so contrary to my values I
21:43
think it raises some important philosophical and even theological points which we'll deal with in the
21:49
interpretation but separate from any question of morality I hope we can see the tensions that live within at least
21:55
some of the men who produce great art yay his story while unique has common
22:00
elements to many artists even today I also hope this historical Journey
22:06
reveals some of the tensions between the traditional values of the 1800s and some of the novel beliefs intimately tied to
22:13
Eastern mysticism sexual Liberation feminism and other social issues that
22:18
were fermenting long before the 1960s we didn't arrive at this historical Moment by accident and as
22:25
usual artists are on the precipitous edge of those shifts and sometimes far
22:31
beyond them with a wild ride firmly in mind this is a dialogue of self and Soul
22:38
by William Butler
Poem Reading 1
22:43
Yates myself a living man is blind and drinks his drop what matter if the
22:49
ditches are impure what matter if I live it all once more endure that toil of
22:55
growing up the ignominy of Boyhood the distress of Boyhood changing into man
23:00
The Unfinished man in his pain brought face to face with his own clumsiness the finished man among his enemies how In
23:07
The Name Of Heaven Can he escape that defiling and disfigured shape the mirror of malicious eyes casts upon his eyes
23:14
until at last he thinks that shape must be his shape and what's the good of an escape if honor find him in the winry
23:21
blast I am content to live it all again and yet again if it be life to pitch
23:26
into the Frog spawn of a blind man's ditch a blind man battering Blind Men or
23:32
into that most Fon ditch of all the Folly that man does or must suffer if he
23:37
Woos a proud woman not Kindred of his soul I am content to follow to its source every event and action or in
23:45
thought measure the lot forgive myself the lot when such as I cast out remorse
23:50
so great a sweetness flows into the breast we must laugh and we must sing We
23:56
are blessed by everything everything we look upon is
Interpretation
24:02
blessed suffice it to say that my interpretation of this poem is different now than the first time I read it it
24:09
came across as a bit more inspiring before I understood Yates and the details of his life so this is going to
24:16
be a fun experiment to separate the wheat from the chaff to see what a value we can take away from this work to
24:22
inspire Our Lives as men it's in there it's just going to take some surgery ALS
24:28
so this episode is going to be a philosophical and Theological deep dive in Parts I've tried to make the language
24:34
as clear as possible Yates wrote quote the mystical life is the center of all
24:40
that I do and all that I think and all that I write and that is absolutely true of this poem there is a lot packed into
24:47
these few short sentences so I've tried to communicate those aspects without burdening the interpretation if you have
24:55
any questions please email me at info@ renov men.com and I'll do my best to
25:00
answer them so let's start with the structure this is actually the second
25:06
half of a longer poem in which Yates is documenting a dialogue between his personal temporal self and his higher
25:13
Immortal Soul his soul is concerned with Transcendence the life above and between
25:19
lives let's say and his self is thinking about Earthly artifacts of life in this
25:25
case a Japanese Samurai sword a quote emblem of love and and War which hearkens back to yates's obsession with
25:31
Japanese theater it's worth noting here that the Eastern mysticism of India particularly Vidant and Zen Buddhism in
25:38
Japan have a great deal in common it's outside of the scope of this podcast but
25:43
if you'd like to know more you can read Orthodoxy and the religion of the future by the brilliant father seraphim Rose
25:50
for the rest of you think of it this way whether drinking beer or sake the endend result is the same intoxication
25:59
so just before the point when we encounter the poem The Soul has made its final argument about Transcendence that
26:05
concludes the first half of the poem in the second half which we're reading yates's personal self then attempts to
26:12
synthesize the first half into something useful for everyday life the notion of
26:18
the self and soul being separate and somewhat independent beings by the way is a core tenant of the mystical view
26:24
whether of east or west remember what he said about mysticism being at the center of his thought and writing he meant it
26:33
before going on I want to acknowledge though his philosophy and theology were questionable and we will question them
26:40
Yates was undoubtedly in possession of a brilliant mind as I mentioned earlier with his wife Georgie and her 4,000
26:47
pages of automatic writing Yates developed his own systematic cosmology
26:52
I'm familiar with different schools of occult thought and Eastern mysticism and they've taken thousands of years to to
26:58
develop Yates developed his own in considerably less time than that so for all his flaws Yates was still a polymath
27:05
and a complished poet dramatist Senator and spiritualist a cult philosophy is
27:11
impossibly complex perhaps intentionally so and that's why it's a trap for so many men including almost for me so
27:19
while I believe Yates misused his gifts as I'll show you his gifts stand on the less I say all this because the first
27:26
half of the poem is d with spiritualist symbolism and philosophy which is why I'm not reading it to properly take it
27:33
apart for you my audience I'd have to understand his cosmology more thoroughly that's a bit outside of my interest at
27:40
the moment but I want you to know that I know from looking at the first half of the poem the man went as deep into
27:46
mysticism as one can go no easy feet so I feel obliged to offer him that gesture
27:51
of respect before I set the preliminary section of the poem aside thankfully yates's mysticism ALS Al shows up in
27:58
this portion of the poem which we'll see so to get back on track this second half
28:04
of the poem is yates's personal self synthesizing the perspectives of his Earthly aspect that lives and dies and
28:11
the Eternal aspect of himself that doesn't and trying to find Harmony between them again the title of the poem
28:18
is a dialogue of self and soul with his self getting the last word the poem is
28:24
structured in four stanzas with the first two being a quasi his hisorical survey of his life as a man and the
28:30
second to being a philosophical statement about that life though it's not clear when the poem was written it
28:36
was published in 1933 just four years before yates's death so it's fair to say
28:42
that this poem is Yates reflecting on his own life in old age which is important to keep in mind let's start
28:48
with the first lines of the poem a living man is blind and drinks his drop
28:54
what matter if the ditches are impure here Yates is making five profound philosophical statements in just 20
29:01
syllables we as living men are blind to aspects of reality we're gifted a small
29:07
portion of Life which we consume we find our way into Troubles of life or ditches
29:13
these troubles are not entirely clean and that the purity of the ditches might not really matter all that much this is
29:20
what I mean by yates's gifts whether you agree with his ideas or not it's a remarkable achievement to say so much
29:28
with such economy of language and that my friends is poetry let's unpack these
29:34
two lines we'll start with blindness how much of our Lives is lived through our
29:39
eyes if you can close your eyes for a moment how much of Life immediately goes
29:44
away with a lack of sight color shape Dimension and movement all vanish we
29:50
have no idea of our true appearance or of anyone else's so Yates is saying that
29:56
no matter how much we perceive even with our five senses intact we are still essentially blind to a massive amount of
30:03
existence drinking a drop makes sense as an image but it's important to note that Yates doesn't say a drop a living man
30:10
drinks his drop it's possessive there's something personal about it it's a drop
30:16
that has been allocated to the man is how I read it as in here's your drop now
30:21
the ditches I think we can picture an impure ditch muddy brackish water trash
30:27
floating in it a thin film of slime on the surface a floating fishbone and
30:32
worse that is an impure ditch a trench that catches runoff water and garbage on
30:38
the side of a road what matter if these episodes of Life are impure uh hold on
30:43
to that next line what matter if I live it all once more and this is yet another
30:49
core tenant of mysticism reincarnation if you've never had this idea explained to you before basically
30:56
it says that some eternal part of us is born over and over again on Earth perhaps in a human body though not
31:03
necessarily that Eternal part of us is the soul the soul when it's reborn takes on a self which it then discards like a
31:10
skin suit for the next goor round of life when a soul takes on a new life it gets a new self maybe this one you're a
31:18
king maybe next one you're a popper maybe the third one you're a child who dies in youth maybe you even get to be a
31:24
Nobel Prize winner let's read these three lines again a living man is blind and drinks his drop what matter if the
31:31
ditches are impure what matter if I live it all once more so in the dialogue of
31:37
self and soul this portion of the poem is the person of William Butler Yates saying the following men are born blind
31:44
and while consuming their portion of Life they stumble into destructive Folly but what does any Folly really matter
31:51
and what does it really matter if you have to do it the same way all over again drinking and stumbling into impure
31:58
ditches remember what I said about the intoxication of mysticism from a Christian perspective
32:04
nothing about this could be more wrong but here's the frustrating part did you notice the rhythm of the lines they're
32:11
written in iic pentameter or pairs of unstressed and stressed syllables a
32:17
living man is blind and drinks his drop what matter if the ditches are impure
32:23
what matter if I live it all once more the choice of meter is not a coincidence
32:29
as we'll see it's not a formality an imitation or just a habit This brilliant
32:34
man with his own personal cosmology and mature use of language is using this model of rhythmic Perfection referencing
32:41
Shakespeare to assert the superiority of his worldview he is making a profound
32:47
theological cosmological philosophical and artistic statement in just 30
32:52
syllables and what's so incredible is that it feels effortless weightless as
32:57
if these these are the most natural sentences in the world the longest word is just two syllables and seven letters
33:04
if you've ever had a writing instructor tell you to make your writing simpler this is what he meant this is Mastery
33:11
because I've spent 800 or so words and 2 hours of writing time to unpack what Yates did in less than one breath so I
33:19
hope you can feel the respect I have for him and his art amongst my disagreement but let's set aside what I
33:26
think you'll know a tree by its fruits right let's continue examining the poem and judge yates's worldview grid based
33:33
on the fruits it's produced in his life the next section of the poem is a survey of the seasons of a man's life I'll read
33:40
it in its entirety and then we'll dissect it endure that toil of growing up the ignominy of Boyhood the distress
33:48
of Boyhood changing into man The Unfinished man and his pain brought face to face with his own clumsiness the
33:55
finished man among his enemies how In The Name Of Heaven Can he escape that defiling and disfigured shape the mirror
34:02
of malicious eyes casts upon his eyes until at last he thinks that shape must be his shape and what's the good of an
34:09
escape if honor find him in the winry blast I found this section of the poem deeply moving on one hand it's his own
34:17
assessment of his personal experience of life and as a man blessed with a keen mind sharp insight and perceptive
34:23
awareness he Bears a heavier burden of Consciousness than many other men and women and do so in some ways life would
34:30
be harder on him than other people who aren't quite as sensitive to their experience but at the same time he hits
34:36
on some Universal themes of all men's lives that I think we can relate to no matter where we are in our journey as
34:42
men the language here is pretty clear except for the word ignominy which means public shame or disgrace so I won't go
34:49
stage by stage through the interpretation but let's pull out some key ideas the first of these two stanzas
34:55
is about the growing up process which Yates describes as a toil to go from Boyhood to manhood to unfinished manhood
35:03
Boyhood can be shameful puberty can be stressful and young adulthood can be uncertain when men are often old enough
35:10
to know how they're supposed to be but too young yet to be it this might be hard for us to understand because we
35:17
live in an era that lionizes youth but in previous stages of History youth was considered a time of preparation for
35:24
manhood so it was both possible and necessary to be critical of the experience today however youth is
35:30
considered the ideal so no matter how far of Youth we are we look back and imagine those days as the goal and this
35:37
is part of the inversion that we're living through with men following women and women following children but not
35:43
children themselves although in some cases that can be true it is the following of Eternal youth this is
35:50
exactly backwards to what it would have been in yates's day where children followed women women followed men and
35:56
Men followed the highest ideal of maturity and wisdom embodied by God you know the old guy in the sky with the
36:02
long white beard yeah that was an ideal but in Mortal men that maturity and
36:08
wisdom can only be acquired in old age after metabolizing Decades of life
36:13
experience so Yates is both being hard on his personal childhood and the notion of childhood itself not just because
36:21
he's making a point but because it's right I did also want to highlight the notion of the unfinished man brought
36:27
face to face with his own clumsiness an unfinished man in yates's day would have been a man in his teens or 20s and again
36:35
today we'd consider that an ideal but such men were considered unfinished and that this was natural because men must
36:42
be cultivated turning a boy into a man is a work of conscious effort over decades by a father a community a
36:50
profession a woman a family and a faith making it through that Gauntlet and
36:55
thriving is what it means to be finished because failure or incompletion can happen at any stage along that path and
37:03
i' reckon that most men you will meet today of any age would be considered unfinished because they've never been
37:10
cultivated so I hope outside our need today for men to be a certain way to resurrect our civilization we can
37:16
recognize that most men live their lives painfully unfinished which is why we can often be so clumsy many men die that way
37:24
too which to me is why the Renaissance is so important the Renaissance is in
37:30
its highest ideal an opportunity for unfinished men to finish ourselves and help each other do so to rid ourselves
37:37
of our pain of clumsiness what Yates took for granted and in many ways was helping to undermine though somewhat
37:44
unintentionally we now have to ReDiscover which I think is why you're all here but after a man becomes
37:51
finished life doesn't get any easier for him the next stanza of the poem reads
37:56
the finished man his enemies how In The Name Of Heaven Can he escape that defiling and disfigured shape the mirror
38:03
of malicious eyes casts upon his eyes until at last he thinks that shape must be his shape this one is tough because
38:11
what Yates is describing here is something I've experienced I reckon it's something that every man has gone
38:16
through or perhaps goes through all the time and undoubtedly women too you work
38:22
hard to finish yourself to cultivate yourself to raise yourself up to a standard you can be proud out of and yet
38:28
what you see reflected in others eyes is a gross and twisted shape that reflects their opinions of you not necessarily
38:35
the truth although how are we supposed to know the difference sometimes in that moment it's easy to mistake those
38:41
opinions for the truth but there's some hope the eyes are malicious for the men
38:47
are enemies it's not simply an honest mistake or a misunderstanding it's active persecution the trick is
38:54
recognizing an enemy when you see one because Yates says says how In The Name Of Heaven Can he escape which is to say
39:01
the finished man must encounter his enemies a man who is finished will
39:06
encounter them how In The Name Of Heaven is a phrase used as a desperate cry how
39:12
In The Name Of Heaven can I escape this impossible thing you can't because Yates
39:18
follows it with and what's the good of an escape if honor find him in the wintry blast the wintry blast means old
39:25
age the message is if a man does find an escape it will be dishonorable and that
39:31
dishonor will find you in old age so this is what the life of a man means to
39:37
Yates shameful Boyhood uncertain adolescence a clumsy and painful young
39:42
adulthood followed by the unavoidable persecution of enemies as an adult that
39:47
cannot be avoided or else you risk your honor what resonates about this is that
39:53
it's true I think every man listening understands this it's not not the entire
39:58
Truth For Life is also full of joy love warmth and fulfillment as well but this
40:03
is the backbone of the truth of what it means to be a man it's what every man must be prepared for if he wishes to
40:10
live and Thrive I ask the women listening to think about the men in your life where are they on this journey
40:18
finished or unfinished can you see them can you give them the gift of understanding that these are the
40:24
currents of life as men that we experience but never say not because we don't have enough words but that it
40:31
takes a genius like Yates to say it so clearly in so few and that is why this
40:37
poem is so difficult for me to read he's right about so much movingly so
40:42
heartbreakingly so and yet and yet before moving on I want to show it to
40:49
you a living man is blind and drinks his drop what matter if the ditches are impure what matter if I live it all once
40:56
more remember how those are in perfect diamic pentameter now what's the very next line
41:03
endure that toil of growing up and then the anomy of Boyhood the distress of
41:09
Boyhood changing into man The Unfinished man in his pain brought face to face with his own clumsiness no I Amic
41:16
pentameter in fact no meter at all a rhythm to the language but no meter the
41:22
message is the I Amic pentameter symbolizes the perspective of the Transcendent soul
41:28
but in the very next step it becomes a personal self enduring the toil of
41:33
growing up from perfected ideal into a flawed and Earthly being do you see it
41:40
do you hear it yates's message in Artistry extends even into his use of
41:46
meter and yet it's so effortless and seamless you'd barely notice it unless
41:51
you look my entire body collapsed in the experience of exquisite beauty when I I
41:57
saw this I was and am AED with appreciation because like gway kennel's
42:03
last Gods this one rang true this is poetry one of the finest examples
42:10
perfectly crystallized for us to see and we must continue on Yates writes I am
42:18
content to live it all again and yet again if it be life to pitch into the Frog spawn of a Blind Man's ditch first
42:26
this is a recapitulation of the first three lines but now with a greater confidence in his assertion there's the
42:33
mystical notion of reincarnation and his stated contentment that life as a man means stumbling blindly into ditches all
42:40
again and yet again and to make sure there's no mistake the ditch contains frog spawn which you only find in shaded
42:47
shallow ponds it's worth noting here that female frogs lay eggs that male frogs fertilize with sperm in the water
42:55
so it's probably not something that a man wants to stumble into and hold on to that thought for a second because once
43:01
again there's the transition from mamic pentameter into a more irregular meter as he goes from ideal into reality I am
43:09
content to live it all again and yet again if it be life to pitch into the Frog spawn of a Blind Man's ditch it's
43:17
almost as if the lines themselves stumble are you seeing this and then the
43:22
line a blind man battering Blind Men the violence in that word battering and the
43:28
brutality of the language in the line each syllable lands like a punch men is
43:34
this not life can you not relate to this and then here comes the kicker or into
43:39
that most Fon ditch of all the Folly that man does or must suffer if he Woos
43:45
a proud woman not Kindred of his soul fund has two definitions according to Miriam Webster First is fruitful in
43:53
Offspring or vegetation and second is intellectually productive or inventive to a marked degree I read these lines
44:00
about modon the word Fon here suggests not only sex but also the power of am
44:06
Muse mod was most definitely that for Yates this ties also to the Frog spawn
44:11
imagery ditches he previously called impure he then abused with the visceral substances of sex that he then stumbles
44:19
into the message is unmistakable Yates stumbles into impure sexual trrs the
44:26
ditch is both fruit in terms of procreation and Imagination but it is folly and she is proud and does not
44:32
share something vital in common with him I think this is about mgon and not yates's wife Georgie first because I
44:40
can't imagine him writing publicly about his wife this way that would be monstrous second because her 4,000 pages
44:47
of automatic writing suggests that she's probably quite Kindred to his soul but
44:52
also because there's that unmistakable note of bitterness calling her proud and
44:57
then the suggestion of her not being kindered of his soul is not a neutral statement it has a value judgment in it
45:03
which we'll see in a second Yates like he did with Major General John McBride is using his pen to slay her Legacy the
45:11
blind man battering Blind Men reference may have actually been about McBride in part but it seems that Yates hasn't
45:17
learned much and sadly it gets worse from here I am content to follow to its
45:23
source every event in action or in thought measure the lot forgive myself
45:28
the lot it's unclear to me whether the source he traces his thoughts and actions to is a singular thing or
45:36
independent for each action or thought is he talking about some ultimate source
45:41
or his reasons for acting and speaking I think it's the latter he knows why he
45:46
thinks what he thinks and does what he does he measures the source and reason of every action and thought and forgives
45:53
himself just a moment ago he cut the memory of of a woman with a single word
45:58
proud and he insulted her as being quote not Kindred of his soul he talks about
46:04
stumbling into impure sexual encounters or ditches being covered in water and
46:09
frog spawn made real in the manifestation of sweat and sperm he like
46:15
the rest of us is a blind man battering other Blind Men and from his history we
46:21
know for a fact he was unfaithful to his wife and insulted the memory of a Dead Soldier who bravely fought and was
46:28
executed for the very chance of a free Ireland that Yates himself later became a Statesman and senator of and this man
46:35
has the tarity the gall the sheer hubris to say I forgive myself and now we're
46:43
going to see how dark it gets when such as I cast out remorse so great a
46:48
sweetness flows into the breast we must laugh and we must sing We are blessed by
46:53
everything everything we look upon is blessed when such as I cast out remorse such as
47:01
I it's hard not to read that as a statement of superiority of ego in the
47:06
worst possible way what is ugly and Vain about a man this is why when he says mod
47:12
gone is not Kindred of his soul he means it as an insult for she is not Kindred with a soul such as he and when he casts
47:20
out remorse for his wrong actions which he himself admits to battering Blind Men
47:25
and stumbling into ditches yes indeed a great sweetness flows into the breast I
47:30
have absolved myself of all responsibility he says I have hurt people by my own admission I've done
47:36
disgusting things I would do it all again and yet again Folly shame
47:42
blindness violence and filth when I forgive myself which such as I am capable of doing I feel such gratitude
47:49
for life I think I'll dance a jig and sing a song look how blessed and holy Everything is Everything I'm looking at
47:56
is blessed oh how lovely to have the power to forgive oneself isn't it amazing what you can do if you have that
48:03
power pretty much anything how fortunate what a blessing to myself I am what a
48:08
blessing I am to everyone what a blessing everyone and everything is to
48:14
me of course I wonder what everyone else thinks of him his wife certainly was
48:19
kinder to him and his folly than she needed to be her own friends warned her against him maybe they were right
48:26
because now we come to the point mysticism has an appeal for men and women because it denies any objective
48:33
standard of morality besides self-interest Alistair Crowley part of the Hermetic Order of the Golden Dawn
48:39
which Yates and his wife were both a part of was famous for saying do what thou Wilt shall be the whole of the law
48:47
in other words the only law the Mystic the occultist the calist needs to follow
48:52
is to do what they want if they have done that they have followed thew law and they are absolved this is probably
48:59
the source that Yates has traced all his thoughts and actions back to to measure himself the lot and forgive himself the
49:06
lot did he do what he wanted then such as he can cast out remorse and let
49:11
sweetness flow into his breast he has pursued naked self-interest pun intended
49:17
he achieved artistic genius no doubt as far as I can tell though contemporary geopolitics played a role he earned that
49:24
Nobel Prize he derived many beautiful truths about life as a man he said true
49:30
things and he said them marvelously literally in ways that I Marvel at I
49:35
also can't be too hard on him because I've stumbled into a few frog spawn ditches myself battered Blind Men And
49:42
even studied with a mystery school that was connected at least tangentially with the Golden Dawn but Yates was also an
49:48
adulterer a philandering old man who fought a Dead Soldier with a pen instead of living ones with his fists he
49:56
publicly promoted traditional Irish history and culture while privately practicing mystical Eastern and occult
50:02
Arts that had nothing to do with it he even said he would do it all again and yet again and in the final analysis at
50:09
least as far as he was concerned he said I forgive myself the lot how does that
50:15
land for you does that feel right or just while you strive to be a good man
50:21
honest in your dealings straightforward in your words reliable and true does it seem fair or even right that a man who
50:28
holds himself to far lower standards can simply say I don't know what yall are talking about with that morality stuff I
50:34
just forgive myself and look what happened everything became blessed does that work for you or do you think
50:42
somewhere in your heart that maybe just maybe we as men and women are accountable to something beyond our
50:48
self-interest that in the final analysis it might be a bit more complicated than I'm sorry will no problem will that
50:56
maybe there is something someone outside of ourselves transcending every broken relationship that we run from forget
51:03
about or slander someone who in the last moment says I saw that and that and that
51:10
too I saw it all it is the avoidance of that knowledge that draws men to occultism to advita Vidant to automatic
51:18
writing of spirits and to gurus who preach that all is one because then no one is accountable for anything because
51:24
everything even the Frog spawn ditch is blessed so stumble into it defile
51:29
yourself harm others aize your own Spirit forgive yourself then do it all
51:35
again and yet again I can't think of a more Grim way of looking at life this is the opposite of blessed this is eternal
51:42
torment made bearable only by one's assertion of superiority over others in the same predicament in other words
51:50
Pride the same thing he accused mod gon of but there is a sign that Yates new
51:56
despite himself the consequences of his actions in a way he couldn't escape this
52:02
poem is the last one in the compilation the Rag and Bone shop of the heart which helped Inspire this series of poetry for
52:09
men the Rag and Bone shop of the heart as we heard in the first half is yates's
52:14
line his own heart is full of nothing but rags and bones and he even describes
52:20
it as foul The Men Who compiled this collection of poetry were Robert blly
52:26
James H hman who was a direct student of Carl Young and the poet Michael me the
52:31
title is meant to evoke their perception of what it means to be men the choice of
52:36
yates's poem to complete the compilation confirms it a Heart full of rags and
52:42
Bones a poetic image romantic even mournful with an empty kind of
52:50
quietness but there is another way that men's Hearts can be you have to give up
52:55
the right to forgive self though you have to serve more than your own self-interest you have to know and be
53:02
comfortable with every action and every thought being traced back to its true Source by one who sees more deeply than
53:10
you that it matters that the ditches are impure and that you don't get to live it
53:15
all once more that as Blind Men we must stop battering other Blind Men life will
53:21
still be difficult yes but maybe with the knowledge that we get just one chance we'll be motivated and
53:28
disciplined enough to do it right our hearts could be that other way as men
53:34
all it costs us is our pride but in that moment we can know there's a man who'll
53:40
take from us our heart of rags and bones and instead give to us a heart of Flesh
53:47
and that might be a blessing worth singing and dancing for once again this is a dialogue of
53:55
self and soul by William Butler
Poem Reading 2
54:02
Yates myself a living man is blind and drinks his drop what matter if the ditches are
54:09
impure what matter if I live it all once more endure that toil of growing up the
54:15
ignominy of Boyhood the distress of Boyhood changing into man The Unfinished
54:20
man in his pain brought face to face with his own clumsiness the finished man among his enemies how In The Name Of
54:27
Heaven Can he escape that defiling and disfigured shape the mirror of malicious eyes casts upon his eyes until at last
54:34
he thinks that shape must be his shape and what's the good of an escape if honor find him in the wintry blast I am
54:41
content to live it all again and yet again if it be life to pitch into the Frog spawn of a Blind Man's ditch a
54:48
blind man battering Blind Men or into that most Fon ditch of all the Folly
54:54
that man does or must suffer if he Woos a proud woman not Kindred of his soul I
55:00
am content to follow to its source every event in action or in thought measure
55:05
the lot forgive myself the lot when such as I cast out remorse so great a
55:10
sweetness flows into the breast we must laugh and we must sing We are blessed by
55:16
everything everything we look upon is blessed
55:21
[Music]
One-on-one biblical mentorship
You love God. So why does your faith feel stuck?
Twelve weeks one-on-one with me, under the authority of Scripture. We start with a three-hour kickoff where youโre heard all the way through.
What men have said
โWillโฆ is really good at taking your situation and putting words to it.โ
Kevin S.
โWillโs not afraid to challenge the false reality.โ
Benito S.
โThe same guy that you hear on the podcastโฆ is the same guy that youโre going to get.โ
Chris Y.





